Increasing the Policy Impact of Ecosystem Service Assessments and Valuations: Insights from Practice

Authors :
Augustin Berghöfer, Claire Brown, Aaron Bruner, Lucy Emerton, Ersin Esen, Davide Geneletti, Marina Kosmus, Ritesh Kumar, Markus Lehmann, Fernando Leon Morales, Ephraim Nkonja, Till Pistorius, Julian Rode, Roel Slootweg, Ulrike Tröger, Heidi Wittmer, Sven Wunder, Hugo van Zyl
Organisation:
Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH, Helmholtz Zentrum für Umweltforschung (UFZ)

Three requirements for increasing the policy impact of Ecosystem Service Assessments and Valuations (ESAVs) have been identified across diverse cases:

  • Balance the trio of credibility, legitimacy and relevance: These key principles for scientific policy advice should guide the assessment design and the process management of an ESAV. However, there are tensions among them which merit attention.
  • Close the loop between ESAV and policy: The assessment process needs to be linked in with public policy-making. Numbers do rarely speak for themselves, and without adequate interaction, ESAV results will likely be ignored, or – worse – misunderstood.
  • Tailor ESAV to its practical purpose: Many different approaches and methods are available, and technical aspects are insufficient for identifying the most appropriate study design. To be effective, ESAVs have to fit their purpose.

UFZ and GIZ have published the paper Increasing the Policy Impact of Ecosystem Service Assessments and Valuations: Insights from Practice. This report is based on a review of past assessments and builds on the authors’ practical experience. It examines these requirements and explores the options for practitioners to respond to them.